My picky eater won't touch the new food! Help!

Started by OP 1/19/2026 07:00 PM

OP
OP
Guest
OP 1/19/2026 07:00 PM
#1
Hey everyone, my 3-year-old lab mix is being so stubborn! I switched to a new brand of kibble (supposedly healthier) and he just sniffs it and walks away. He'll eat treats but ignores his meals. Anyone have tips for getting a picky dog to eat new food? Or good toppers that might help? Brands that worked for your fussy pets?
Sent from PetDeals Club Community 🔗 Permalink
ChowChowCharlie758
ChowChowCharlie758
New Member
1/19/2026 08:25 PM
#2
I feel you! My chow chow does this every time I try to save money with a new brand lol. What worked for me: mixing in a spoonful of canned pumpkin (not pie filling!) or a bit of plain yogurt. Also, check Chewy's deals section—sometimes they have sample packs of different brands so you can test without committing to a big bag. I got my dog to finally eat the Costco brand after adding some bone broth (low sodium!).
Sent from PetDeals Club Community 🔗 Permalink
VetVicky352
VetVicky352
New Member
1/19/2026 10:26 PM
#3
As a big dog lover (I have two Danes!), I'd suggest ruling out health issues first—sudden refusal to eat can sometimes mean dental pain or tummy trouble. If he's healthy, try a slow transition: mix 25% new food with 75% old for a few days, then 50/50, etc. For toppers, a little warm water or low-sodium chicken broth can make the kibble smell more appealing. Avoid too many rich toppers long-term though—can cause pickiness!
Sent from PetDeals Club Community 🔗 Permalink
ShibaSteve956
ShibaSteve956
New Member
1/20/2026 01:36 AM
#4
lol my shiba client does this all the time—they're so dramatic about food changes! One trick that works for some dogs I walk: sprinkle a tiny bit of parmesan cheese (the powdery kind) or crumble a freeze-dried liver treat on top. Also, make sure you're not over-treating between meals! Sometimes they hold out for the good stuff. I've seen dogs finally cave after 12 hours, but check with your vet if you're worried.
Sent from PetDeals Club Community 🔗 Permalink
LizardLarry135
LizardLarry135
New Member
1/20/2026 03:44 AM
#5
Not a dog expert but my bearded dragon did this with new greens once—turns out he just wanted them chopped finer! Maybe try wetting the kibble or mixing with a bit of the old food? Also, consistency in feeding times helped my reptile adjust. Good luck!
Sent from PetDeals Club Community 🔗 Permalink

Join the conversation

You must be logged in to reply to this thread. Log in or Register to participate.